From the Bakery

75 years of stories worth telling.

The cookie that sold to Eat'n Park. The WWII bread that became a keto legend. The designer who walked into a 75-year-old institution and found her calling.

A custom cake designed in Warner's Cake Studio, the bakery's 3D cake designer
What's New
3 min read

Design Your Own Cake, From Your Couch

Warner's now has a 3D cake designer built right into the website — custom-built by Forever Still Studio. Build your cake, pick the colors and decorations, spin it around, and send it straight to Hilary.

Read the story →
Warner's original Smiley Cookie
Origin Story
5 min read

The Cookie That Became Eat'n Park

In 1949, Ellsworth Warner baked a cheerful frosted cookie that made Titusville smile. In 1986, a restaurant founder drove up from Pittsburgh and bought the recipe. Here's the full story.

Read the story →
Warner's GLUTEN Bread loaf
The Recipe
4 min read

A 1940s Wartime Recipe That Accidentally Invented Keto Bread

Sugar was rationed. Dairy was scarce. So Ellsworth Warner made bread with four ingredients. 80 years later, the keto and diabetic communities found it — and they won't let it go.

Read the story →
Hilary Hanna, owner of Warner's Bakery By Hil
Meet the Baker
6 min read

She Studied Architecture. Then She Found Her True Calling.

Hilary Hanna spent about ten years working at architecture firms in Buffalo and Erie before finding Warner's Bakery — a 75-year-old institution in need of someone who understood structure. Turns out, design and baking aren't that different.

Read the story →
Long Johns and donuts fried fresh every morning at Warner's Bakery
Heritage
3 min read

Still Made By Hand: The Story of Warner's Long Johns

Every Warner's Long John is made completely by hand by Hilary's husband, Dustin — the same old-fashioned way for decades, from a recipe nobody can quite date.

Read the story →
Smiley Cookies handed out after school at Warner's Bakery, Titusville
Community
3 min read

Every Day After School

The bell rings. Some kids walk past Warner's on Franklin Street. Some walk in. Hilary is usually there, and sometimes there are cookies left over. She hands them out. No charge. No announcement. Just what it means to run a bakery in the town where you live.

Read the story →