Our Menu

Fresh from the oven. Just for you.

Everything on our menu is baked from scratch every morning, right here in Titusville. Order online for pickup, walk in for the full case, or call ahead for special orders.

Order Online for Pickup → Call (814) 827-2330

Prices change seasonally. For current pricing, call (814) 827-2330 or stop in.

Made Fresh Daily
Cookies
The Original Smiley Cookie

The one that started it all. Soft, frosted, and smiling.

Chocolate Chip

Hand-scooped, soft center, crisp edge.

Seasonal Selections

Ask in store for today's specials.

Fried Fresh Every Morning
Donuts, Long Johns & Pastries
Cream-Filled Long Johns

Fried fresh every morning.

Glazed Donuts

Classic, fresh, perfect.

Cinnamon Rolls

Warm. Gooey. Worth waking up for.

Baked from Scratch
Breads
GLUTEN Bread

The 1940s low-carb legend — about 2g net carbs per slice. Read the story →
Contains wheat & gluten · not gluten-free

Artisan White

Soft, golden crust, classic crumb.

Custom & Classic
Cakes & Cupcakes
Custom Birthday Cakes

From a simple sheet cake to a tiered showstopper.

Cupcakes by the Dozen

Made fresh, frosted beautifully.

Wedding Cakes

See our Wedding Consultation page →

Pulled by Hand
Specialty Coffee

We proudly brew Mill Creek Coffee — a veteran- and family-owned roaster right up the road in Erie, PA.

Espresso

Pulled by hand.

Lattes

Made with care, art that holds.

Drip Coffee

Classic and reliable, every morning.

Custom & Wedding Cakes

Dreaming up something special?

Custom cakes and cupcakes are made to order. Start your design in Warner's Cake Studio, or book a complimentary wedding consultation — up to 1 hour.

Design Your Cake → Wedding Cakes →

Ready to order?

Order online for pickup or give us a call.

Order Online → Call (814) 827-2330