Birthplace of the Smiley Cookie · Titusville, PA · Since 1949

The Bakery That
Started the Smiley.

Since 1949, Warner's Bakery has been hand-mixing, hand-rolling, and hand-frosting in the heart of Titusville, PA. From the original Smiley Cookie to custom wedding cakes that steal the show, we bake the kind of memories you'll talk about for years.

Order Online → Design Your Wedding Cake → Book a Wedding Consultation →
1949 · Family-baked since
·
2 Locations
·
4-ingredient GLUTEN bread
Fresh Today
Four-tier custom wedding cake with hand-painted floral decorations by Warner's Bakery By Hil, Titusville, PA
Hand-Baked
Daily
Since 1949
Why Warner's

Lovingly made — just for you.

Handcrafted with love

Every cookie shaped, every cake frosted, every loaf scored by hand. The way Mr. Warner did it in 1949 — and the way we still do it today.

Freshly baked every day

From breads and donuts to cookies and pastries, we bake fresh throughout the week so our cases are filled with the favorites our customers know and love.

Only the good stuff

Quality ingredients, time-tested recipes, and generations of baking tradition. Just the way baking should be.

The Origin Story

A cookie so famous it became Eat'n Park.

In the 1940s, Ellsworth Warner started baking a cheerful, frosted cookie that made people grin before they even took a bite. It became a Titusville icon — and in 1986, restaurant founder Jim Broadhurst bought the recipe and turned it into the face of Eat'n Park.

Every Smiley Cookie you've ever seen? It started here. On Franklin Street. In our ovens.
Get the Original Smiley →
The original Smiley Cookie, baked fresh at Warner's Bakery in Titusville, PA
1949
The Original
What Hilary Inherited

The only place to get the original Smiley Cookie.

If you want the original Smiley Cookie — not the chain version, but the actual, first-made, Ellsworth Warner recipe Smiley Cookie — there's only one place to get it.

Born in a Main Street garage in 1949 and still made in Titusville today, the original Smiley Cookie remains exactly what it has always been: soft, hand-frosted, and made with pride.

And it's not going anywhere.

Fresh Today

What we bake fresh every morning.

The original Smiley Cookie at Warner's Bakery
The Original

The Smiley Cookie

The cookie that started it all. Soft, frosted, and grinning back at you. Bring a dozen home — they don't last the drive.

Warner's GLUTEN Bread — low carb, 4 ingredients
Keto Friendly

GLUTEN Bread

A 1940s wartime recipe with just 4 ingredients. 2 carbs per slice. No sugar, no dairy, no fat. A beloved favorite for 80+ years.

Custom wedding cake by Warner's Bakery, Titusville PA
Custom Orders

Wedding Cakes

Designed by a trained baker with a designer's eye. Tiered, sculpted, hand-painted — whatever your "I do" deserves.

Fresh donuts and long johns baked daily at Warner's Bakery
Fried Fresh Daily

Long Johns & Donuts

Fried fresh every morning. Glazed, filled, frosted — the way your grandmother remembers.

Fresh cinnamon rolls baked every morning at Warner's Bakery
Baked Fresh

Cinnamon Rolls

Warm. Gooey. Worth waking up for.

Specialty espresso and lattes at Warner's Bakery
Specialty Coffee

Espresso & Lattes

Espresso pulled by hand, lattes that hold their art — brewed with Mill Creek Coffee, a veteran- and family-owned roaster out of Erie, PA. Pair anything in the case with a cup that won't disappoint.

See the Full Menu → Order Online →
Loved in Titusville Since 1949

What our customers say.

★★★★★

"A hidden gem! Stop in for coffee and a sweet treat. The donuts and filled cookies were delicious. The white cake with butter cream was to die for and perfect with a hot cup of coffee."

Frugal Family Farm House
Google Review
★★★★★

"Thank you Warners for making the most perfect cake for my baby's first birthday!! I highly recommend, it turned out even better than the inspo pic!"

Leigha Cook
Google Review
★★★★★

"They have the best chocolate flavor we have ever had plus the frosting is great. Cookies and all baked goods are delicious. Our sons birthday cake for his second birthday was the coolest and dont mind paying the extra for top of the line."

Ryan Rubaker
Local Guide · Google Review
Read more reviews on Google →
Fresh from the Kitchen

Every cake is a custom creation.

Custom cake by Warner's Bakery By Hil
Custom cake by Warner's Bakery By Hil
Custom cake by Warner's Bakery By Hil
Custom cake by Warner's Bakery By Hil
Wedding cake by Warner's Bakery By Hil
Custom cake by Warner's Bakery By Hil
Custom cake by Warner's Bakery By Hil
Custom cake by Warner's Bakery By Hil
Custom cake by Warner's Bakery By Hil
Follow @warnersbakerybyhil for more →
Warner's Cake Studio

Design your dream cake before you come in.

Our interactive 3D cake designer lets you play with tiers, flavors, and decorations. Try it for free — then bring your design to your consultation and we'll make it real.

Open Cake Studio →

Free to use. No account required.

Find Us

Two locations. One recipe book.

⭐ Year-Round

Titusville

115 North Franklin St.
Titusville, PA 16354

Hours

Mon – Thu8:30 AM – 4 PM
Friday8:30 AM – 5 PM
Saturday8:30 AM – 4 PM
SundayClosed
📞 (814) 827-2330 📱 Text (814) 350-4901
Get Directions →
🌿 Seasonal

Tionesta

Tionesta Market Village
300 Elm St., Tionesta, PA 16353

Hours

Friday9:30 AM – 4 PM
Saturday9 AM – 4 PM
Sunday10 AM – 2 PM

Closed Nov 30 · Reopening in spring.

📞 (814) 827-2330
Get Directions →
Stay in the Loop

Fresh from the oven. Into your inbox.

Seasonal specials, new menu items, and stories from the bakery. No spam — just good things from Titusville.

Unsubscribe anytime. We respect your inbox.